Skip to main content

Module 9: Brixton Brothers Book 2- The Ghostwriter Secret by Mac Barnett


Genre: Mystery

Book Summary:
Steve Brixton is a preteen with a keen eye and a bit of a know-it-all attitude.  He is intent on fulfilling his dream to become a private detective, and he is certain that he has a better chance at solving a mystery than any adult might, even when that adult is his mother's police boyfriend.  Brixton is contacted by his idol, a mystery writer named Bart, to help with a case.  Steve doesn't really have a brother, but his best friend tags along to help.  The two soon discover there is much at risk, even being shot at as the run from the B Syndicate.  They must save a red diamond, a famous author, and themselves.

Barnett, Mac. (2010). The Ghostwriter Secret. NY: Simon and Schuster Books for Young Readers.

Impressions:
I was a huge fan of Encyclopedia Brown as a kid, so Steve Brixton had some pretty big shoes to fill.  Granted, I was not the target audience for this book.  It is a typical genius kid who shows up every adult kind of fare.  There are plenty of puns and detective noir kind of cheese.  The story tends to be over the top and not exactly believable.  It also isn't exactly the kind of mystery where you can follow along and try to solve it with the protagonist.

Still, there is adventure and the makings of a good story.  Mac Barnett is a good storyteller and Adam Rex is a great illustrator.  Together, they have created a detective team that has the potential to interest many preteen readers, especially boys.  Barnett throws in all the elements a boy might crave in a story, and one can't help but wonder if he's not living out his childhood fantasies through Steve Brixton and Dana.  While I'm not sure the series will have the staying power of Sherlock Holmes or my favorite, Encyclopedia Brown, I do see value in having it on the shelf.

Professional Review:
Partially thanks to his solving The Case of the Case of Mistaken Identity (2009), 12-year-old Steve Brixton has been able to start his own detective agency. Now he’s a real sleuth like his heroes, the fictional Bailey Brothers, no matter what his mother’s lame, cop boyfriend Rick might say to the contrary. Steve gets a call from Victor Fairview, the richest man in Ocean Park, Calif., when Fairview’s red diamond goes missing. Steve solves that case in less than an hour despite Rick’s interference. While charged with guarding the diamond, Steve gets a letter from his idol, MacArthur Bart, author of the Bailey Brothers books. Bart needs Steve’s help! With best friend Dana in tow, Steve sets out to find Bart. Can a detective weaned on a couple of 1950s Hardy Boys clones solve a case with more twists than a…a really twisty thing? Barnett’s second Brixton Brothers mystery continues the whimsically sardonic adventures of everyone’s soon-to-be-favorite clueless-yet-earnest boy detective–wannabe. Shot through with moments of goofiness and dotted with Rex’s black-and-white illustrations, this is sure to please existing fans and win new ones. (Mystery. 8-12)

Kirkus (2010). [Review for the book The Ghostwriter Secret].   Retrieved from https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/mac-barnett/ghostwriter-secret/

 Library Uses:
Mac Barnett uses some interesting techniques to build on the character of Steve Brixton. One of my favorite is the decision for Steve to call his agency Brixton Brothers, despite the fact that he is an only child.  This says so much about Steve as a person, and what he values or hopes for.  Using this as a discussion starter for character development and author techniques for creating characters could lead to some great insights.  Allowing students to develop their own characters for a potential mystery story would be fun.  They could develop the detective, the victim, or even the villain.

 Readalikes :
Eddie: The Lost Youth of Edgar Allen Poe by Scott Gustafson
Cam Jansen Mysteries by David A. Adler
Masterpiece by Elise Broach

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Module 1- Runaway Bunny by Margaret Wise Brown

Genre: Picture Book Book Summary: Little bunny imagines with his mother what might happen were he to run away from her.  His imaging grows bigger and wilder each time, but each time, his mother is there to remind him how much she cares. Brown, M. W., & Hurd, C. (1972). The runaway bunny . New York: Harper & Row. Impressions: Children often ask "what if," and sometimes, they ask the questions of adults to reaffirm that everything will be okay.  Runaway Bunny is a story that gets to the heart of a child's fear of abandonment and a mother's reassurance that she will always do whatever she can to keep her child safe and by her side.  The story is a sweet reminder for both child and adult of just how deep a parent's love it. Professional Review: " This is one of the nicest things Margaret Wise Brown has done, and Clement Hurd has made enchanting pictures, with line drawings and eight double spreads in four colors, beautifully reproduced. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Module 7: Ninth Ward by Jewell Parker Rhodes

Genre : Realistic Fiction Book Summary : Lanesha is a girl living in New Orleans right before Hurricane Katrina hits.  She is adopted by an older lady, Mama Ya-Ya, who has a special ability to see the future.  Lanesha, herself, is gifted with seeing things that others cannot, and for this, she is often made fun of.  Still, she manages to befriend a boy, TaShon, and when the storm hits, they depend on one another for survival. Rhodes, J. P. (2010). Ninth ward (1st ed.). New York: Little, Brown and Co. Impressions : This is the first novel I have read related to Hurricane Katrina, and while I remember it vividly, I viewed it as an outsider.  Rhodes does a good job putting the reader into the shoes of the people who were living in the Ninth Ward at the time of the hurricane.  While there are some supernatural elements within the story, they help the define the culture of some of the people living in the area.  Overall, the story gives insight int...
Post a Comment
Read more

Module 8: The Grimm Legacy by Polly Shulman

Genre : Fantasy Book Summary : Elizabeth is a lonely teen at a new school, just trying to fit in somewhere.  She takes up the chance to work at the New York Circulating Material Repository, a kind of library for objects.  Soon, she learns that some of the objects are less than ordinary, and in fact, many are down right magical.  As is the case with magic, evil is lurking nearby, and soon, some of the pages Elizabeth works with disappear.  She must use he newfound talents and sometimes some of the repository's objects to help her save her friends. Shulman, Polly. (2010). The Grimm legacy . NY: G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers. Impressions: Elizabeth has the absolute dream job- essentially, she works in a library of actual artifacts from the worlds best stories.  They are not just a figment of her imagination- the items are real.  Throughout the book, I kept wishing that I could work at such a place.  The author has seamlessl...
Post a Comment
Read more